New Years Savings! Get from 10 to 15% off your Entire Order. *Discounts do not apply to shipping costs or outdoor furniture
Amish Outlet Store
0 in quote
MENU
  • Living Room
    • Shop by Collection
    • Bookcases
    • Clocks
    • Coffee Tables
    • Curios & Display Cases
    • Early American
    • End Tables
    • Entertainment Centers
    • Fireplaces
    • Futons
    • Gun Cabinets
    • Occasional Tables
    • Amish Pet Furniture
    • Rockers and Gliders
    • Sofa Tables
    • Sofas & Chairs
  • Bedroom
    • Shop by Collection
    • Build Your Collection
    • Beds
    • Blanket Chests
    • Chevals and Mirrors
    • Drawer Chests
    • Dressers
    • Jewelry Chests
    • Dressing Tables
    • Nightstands
    • Valets
    • Baby Furniture
    • Amish Child Rockers
    • Children’s Furniture
    • Amish Rocking Horses
    • Bathroom Vanities
    • Amish Pet Furniture
    • Holin Bed – Direct Ships in 4 Weeks
  • Dining
    • Shop by Collection
    • Barstools
    • Benches & Hall Seats
    • Breakfast Nook Sets
    • Clocks
    • Cabinets
    • Chairs
    • Tables
    • Hutches
    • Pie Safes
    • Servers
    • Wine Cabinets
    • Youth Chairs
    • Pine Kitchen Furniture
  • Office
    • Shop by Collection
    • Bookcases
    • Conference Tables
    • Credenzas
    • Desk Chairs
    • Desks
    • File Cabinets
    • Printer Stands
    • Sewing Centers
    • All Office Furniture
  • Outdoor
    • Accessories
    • Benches
    • Chairs
    • Gliders
    • Occasional Tables
    • Rockers
    • Swings
    • Tables
    • Amish Shed Kits
  • In-Stock
  • Quick Ship
  • Contact Us
  • Blog
  • My Account
  • About
  • Customer Service
  • (330) 669-9919
About Shipping Support Blog
0 in quote
  • Living Room
    • Shop by Collection
    • Bookcases
    • Clocks
    • Coffee Tables
    • Curios & Display Cases
    • Early American
    • End Tables
    • Entertainment Centers
    • Fireplaces
    • Futons
    • Gun Cabinets
    • Occasional Tables
    • Amish Pet Furniture
    • Rockers and Gliders
    • Sofa Tables
    • Sofas & Chairs
    See Collections
  • Bedroom
    • Shop by Collection
    • Build Your Collection
    • Beds
    • Blanket Chests
    • Chevals and Mirrors
    • Drawer Chests
    • Dressers
    • Jewelry Chests
    • Dressing Tables
    • Nightstands
    • Valets
    • Baby Furniture
    • Amish Child Rockers
    • Children’s Furniture
    • Amish Rocking Horses
    • Bathroom Vanities
    • Amish Pet Furniture
    • Holin Bed – Direct Ships in 4 Weeks
    See Collections
  • Dining
    • Shop by Collection
    • Barstools
    • Benches & Hall Seats
    • Breakfast Nook Sets
    • Clocks
    • Cabinets
    • Chairs
    • Tables
    • Hutches
    • Pie Safes
    • Servers
    • Wine Cabinets
    • Youth Chairs
    • Pine Kitchen Furniture
    See Collections
  • Office
    • Shop by Collection
    • Bookcases
    • Conference Tables
    • Credenzas
    • Desk Chairs
    • Desks
    • File Cabinets
    • Printer Stands
    • Sewing Centers
    • All Office Furniture
    See Collections
  • Outdoor
    • Accessories
    • Benches
    • Chairs
    • Gliders
    • Occasional Tables
    • Rockers
    • Swings
    • Tables
    • Amish Shed Kits
    See Collections
  • In-Stock
  • Quick Ship
  • Contact Us
  • Blog
  • My Account
  • About
  • Customer Service
  • (330) 669-9919

Pie Safe/Jelly Cupboard

Home|Product shipping classes|Pie Safe/Jelly Cupboard|Page 3

Showing 25–36 of 39 results

  • Mission Jelly Safe with Drawer

    Amish Mission Jelly Safe with Drawer

    $1,109.00 – $1,373.00Price range: $1,109.00 through $1,373.00 View Product
  • Mission Jelly Safe with Drawer & Copper

    Amish Mission Jelly Safe with Drawer & Copper

    $1,218.00 – $1,516.00Price range: $1,218.00 through $1,516.00 View Product
  • Mission Large Pie Safe

    Amish Mission Large Pie Safe

    $1,592.00 – $2,003.00Price range: $1,592.00 through $2,003.00 View Product
  • Mission Large Pie Safe with Drawers

    Amish Mission Large Pie Safe with Drawers

    $1,848.00 – $2,323.00Price range: $1,848.00 through $2,323.00 View Product
  • Mission Pie Safe with Copper

    Amish Mission Pie Safe with Copper

    $1,294.00 – $1,615.00Price range: $1,294.00 through $1,615.00 View Product
  • Mission Pie Safe with Drawers

    Amish Mission Pie Safe with Drawers

    $1,707.00 – $2,142.00Price range: $1,707.00 through $2,142.00 View Product
  • Amish Modesto Jelly Safe

    Amish Modesto Jelly Safe

    $1,548.00 – $1,947.00Price range: $1,548.00 through $1,947.00 View Product
  • Amish Modesto Jelly Safe with Copper

    Amish Modesto Jelly Safe with Copper

    $1,548.00 – $1,947.00Price range: $1,548.00 through $1,947.00 View Product
  • Modesto Jelly Safe with Glass

    Amish Modesto Jelly Safe with Glass

    $1,623.00 – $2,045.00Price range: $1,623.00 through $2,045.00 View Product
  • Amish Modesto Pie Safe

    Amish Modesto Pie Safe

    $2,291.00 – $2,900.00Price range: $2,291.00 through $2,900.00 View Product
  • Amish Modesto Pie Safe with Copper

    Amish Modesto Pie Safe with Copper

    $2,291.00 – $2,900.00Price range: $2,291.00 through $2,900.00 View Product
  • Modesto Pie Safe with Glass

    Amish Modesto Pie Safe with Glass

    $2,302.00 – $3,198.00Price range: $2,302.00 through $3,198.00 View Product
Page 3 of 4«1234»

Collection Includes

  • Amish Modesto Leg Bench

    Amish Modesto Leg Bench

    $470.00 – $650.00Price range: $470.00 through $650.00 View Product
  • Amish Modesto Chair

    Amish Modesto Chair

    $398.00 – $592.00Price range: $398.00 through $592.00 View Product
  • Amish Modesto Sideboard

    Amish Modesto Sideboard

    $2,392.00 – $3,052.00Price range: $2,392.00 through $3,052.00 View Product
  • Amish Modesto Storage Bench

    Amish Modesto Storage Bench

    $1,346.00 – $1,905.00Price range: $1,346.00 through $1,905.00 View Product
  • Amish Modesto Bench

    Amish Modesto Bench

    $759.00 – $1,317.00Price range: $759.00 through $1,317.00 View Product
  • Amish Modesto Pie Safe

    Amish Modesto Pie Safe

    $2,291.00 – $2,900.00Price range: $2,291.00 through $2,900.00 View Product
  • Amish Modesto Bench

    Amish Modesto Bench

    $771.00 – $1,352.00Price range: $771.00 through $1,352.00 View Product
  • Amish Modesto Buffet

    Amish Modesto Buffet

    $3,503.00 – $4,412.00Price range: $3,503.00 through $4,412.00 View Product
  • Amish Modesto 2-Door Bench

    Amish Modesto 2-Door Bench

    $1,182.00 – $1,630.00Price range: $1,182.00 through $1,630.00 View Product
  • Amish Modesto Pie Safe with Copper

    Amish Modesto Pie Safe with Copper

    $2,291.00 – $2,900.00Price range: $2,291.00 through $2,900.00 View Product

testimonials Scott in Boston, MA

“

I purchased a dining table from your company. It turned out beautifully! It was hand delivered to my home and the men offered to set it up for me. I appreciate the quality craftsmanship and their kindness. First class service!

”

Our Customers Love Us!

Join 5,500+ Subscribers!

Sign up for furniture guides and insights twice a month!

  • Living Room
  • Bedroom
  • Dining
  • Rustic/Barnwood
  • Office
  • Outdoor
  • In-Stock
  • Quick Ship
  • Contact Us
  • Blog
amish outlet store logo
  • amish outlet store address PO Box 396, Smithville, OH 44677
  • amish outlet store phone number (330) 669-9919
  • amish outlet store email addresscustomerservice@amishoutletstore.com
  • nfib logo
  • visa logo
  • bbb accredited business logo
  • Consumer Reviews - Sitejabber
    Reviewed
  • Login
amish outlet store logo
  • amish outlet store address PO BOX 396, SMITHVILLE, OH 44677
  • amish outlet store phone numberTap to
    Call
  • amish outlet store email addressTap to
    Email
  • Login
  • nfib logo
  • visa logo
  • bbb accredited business logo
  • Consumer Reviews - Sitejabber
    Reviewed
amish outlet store logo
Login

  • amish outlet store address PO BOX 396, SMITHVILLE, OH 44677
  • amish outlet store phone numberTap to
    Call
  • amish outlet store email addressTap to
    Email

  • nfib logo
  • bbb accredited business logo
  • visa logo
  • Consumer Reviews - Sitejabber
    Reviewed
  • © 2026 Amish Outlet Store
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Site Credits
  • Site Map
  • Amish Outlet - Facebook Icon Amish Outlet - Instagram Icon Amish Outlet - Pinterest Icon

Amish Outlet Store Process

1Browse our inventory of over 8,000 Amish made furniture pieces. You select the wood type, stain color, and upholstery options.

2Add items to your Quote cart as you shop. Once you have chosen the perfect furniture for your home, review items in your cart, and complete the checkout process.

3A helpful Customer Service Rep will then contact you to answer any questions and provide a full quote.

4A 50% down payment gets your order started. We will mail up to 4 stain or upholstery samples (at no charge) for your review.

5Once completed, our Shipping Department will contact your with delivery details.

Dark blue video thumbnail with white play button in center Are you a visual person? Check out our video to see how easy our process is!

Browse our Inventory